Mocap Resources
Magnetic Motion Capture
Motion capture is typically accomplished by any of three technologies: Optical, Magnetic and Electro Mechanical. While each technology has its strengths, there is not a single motion capture technology that is perfect for every possible use.
Magnetic Motion Capture Systems
Magnetic motion capture systems utilize sensors placed on the body to measure the low-frequency magnetic field generated by a transmitter source. The sensors and source are cabled to an electronic control unit that correlates their reported locations within the field. The electronic control units are networked with a host computer that uses a software driver to represent these positions and rotations in 3D space.
Magnetic systems use 6 to 11 or more sensors per person to record body joint motion. The sensors report position and rotational information. Inverse kinematics (IK) is used to solve the angles for the various body joints, and compensate for the fact that the sensors are offset from the actual joint's center of rotation. The IK approach produces passable results from 6 sensor systems, but IK generally adds system overhead that can cause latency in real-time feedback. Although 6 sensor systems are less expensive, they are more likely to produce 'joint popping' since the IK solution needs to guess about a lot of the information it is receiving. The markers tend to move a bit during capture sessions, and require repeated readjustment and recalibration. Since each sensor requires its own (fairly thick) shielded cable, the tether used by magnetic systems can be quite cumbersome.
DC Magnetic systems have issues with azimuth. If an actor is doing a push-up type posture, the system will get confused. Multiple actor magnetic setups also have problems with two or more actors in close proximity. Sensors from the different actors will interfere with each other, providing distorted results.
DC Magnetic systems have very negative reactions to metal or magnetic fields in the environment. Often a stage can be built to lessen interference from metal in floors, but metal in walls, ceilings, structures, props and interference caused by electrical devices is another story. We've heard of companies resorting to setting up in a parking lot just to get away from metal. Setting up a DC magnetic system in an uncontrolled environment, such as at a trade show can be a harrowing experience. We receive a lot of interest in the Gypsy motion capture system from people who have DC magnetic systems they aren't using due to difficulties with metal in the environment.
In summary, DC magnetic motion-capture systems have the following shortcomings:
-
Sensitivity to metal
-
Limited range
-
Slippage of markers
-
Markers offset from actual joint centers
-
Repeated re-calibration
-
Encumbrance
-
Low effective sampling rate
-
Latency
-
Azimuth problems
-
Proximity based distortion with multiple actors
-
Lower sampling rates due to noise filtering